When a Dalit in India converts to Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, or Sikhism, what changes? The faith, the rituals, perhaps the name – but rarely the social position. Caste, it turns out, is not a religious institution that can be shed by changing one’s religion. It is a social structure so deeply embedded in the fabric of Indian life that it follows converts across religious boundaries, often outlasting any theological promise of equality. The story of Dalit conversion in India is therefore not simply a story of spiritual seeking. It is a story of people trying – often desperately – to escape a system that has marginalized them for centuries, only to find that the system comes with them.
Table of Contents
- Why Dalits convert: the promise of equality
- The persistence of caste across religious lines
- Caste within Christianity
- Caste within Islam: the Ashraf-Ajlaf-Arzal hierarchy
- Caste within Sikhism and Buddhism
- The double bind: losing state protection upon conversion
- Why caste survives conversion: the structural explanation
- Resistance and the limits of religious solutions
Why Dalits convert: the promise of equality
The motivations behind Dalit conversions are unmistakable. Dalits have not been converting simply because they prefer a different belief system – they convert because they actively reject Hinduism and the caste-based degradation it has historically sanctioned. The logic is straightforward: if caste oppression is legitimized by a religious framework, then leaving that framework should, in theory, mean leaving the oppression behind. Across centuries, this reasoning has drawn Dalits toward Christianity, Islam, Sikhism, and Buddhism as alternative social worlds that, at least doctrinally, promise human equality.
The most iconic expression of this logic came from Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, the architect of India’s Constitution and the towering figure of the Dalit movement. His famous declaration – “I was born a Hindu, but I will not die a Hindu” – captured his conviction that the caste system was theologically inseparable from Hinduism. On October 14, 1956, Ambedkar fulfilled this pledge when he and several hundred thousand followers embraced Buddhism in a mass conversion at Nagpur – a social and political act aimed at rejecting caste oppression and establishing a new identity grounded in equality and human dignity. Ambedkar chose Buddhism specifically because, as he argued, it denied caste and rejected a God-ordered and immutable system of social inequality.
The 1956 mass conversion set off a movement. Nearly half a million Dalits joined Ambedkar and converted to Navayana Buddhism, rejecting Hinduism and challenging the caste system while promoting Dalit rights. Conversions to Islam had similarly practical roots. In 1981, hundreds of Dalits in Meenakshipuram, Tamil Nadu, embraced Islam, and in 2017, mass conversion threats were reported from Aligarh and Saharanpur as communities protested ongoing untouchability. The promise of a caste-free religious identity remained a powerful draw – but the promise rarely survived contact with social reality.
The persistence of caste across religious lines
The central and sobering truth about Dalit conversions in India is that when Dalits switch to other religious faiths and encounter the same caste distinctions in different forms, they realize the change neither improves their social status nor remedies their economic problems – the real sources of their discrimination. Caste in India is not simply a Hindu phenomenon. It is a social logic of hierarchy, purity, and pollution that has proven capable of infiltrating virtually every religious community it has encountered.
Caste within Christianity
Despite their conversion to Christianity, Dalit Christians often continue to face societal discrimination both within and outside their religious community due to the pervasive influence of the caste system. Although Christian missionaries in colonial India actively sought to dismantle caste hierarchies within the Church, caste-based practices have persisted in various forms. Even after conversion, Dalits were discriminated against due to “residual leftover” practices of caste discrimination from their previous traditions – sometimes the only change was their personal religious identity, while in many cases they were still referred to by their Hindu caste names.
The practices are not merely informal. Discrimination against Dalit Christians has included separate entrances for Dalits in churches, separate seating, the non-acceptance of Dalit priests, and occupational patterns – including manual scavenging – that closely mirror those of Dalit Hindus. Inter-caste marriage remains uncommon: Syrian Christians in Kerala, for instance, traditionally do not marry Dalit Christians, and in some cases, marriage to a higher-caste Hindu is preferred over marriage to a Dalit Christian. In many churches, Dalit converts were referred to as “New Christians” – a label widely regarded as derogatory.
The discrimination has been significant enough to draw institutional attention. During the 2003 ad limina visits of Indian bishops, Pope John Paul II criticized caste discrimination within the Catholic Church in India, calling it the Church’s obligation to work to see every human being as a child of God. Yet acknowledgment at the top has not dismantled the practices at the community level.
Caste within Islam: the Ashraf-Ajlaf-Arzal hierarchy
Islam’s theological commitment to universal brotherhood and equality before God is explicit and unambiguous. Yet the social history of South Asian Islam tells a different story. A system of social stratification developed in South Asian Muslim communities as a result of relations among foreign conquerors, upper-caste Hindu converts to Islam, and lower-caste local converts – alongside the continuation of Hindu caste practices by converts themselves.
This stratification produced three broad categories. The Ashraf – those claiming descent from Arab, Persian, or Afghan Muslim immigrants, or from upper-caste Hindu converts – occupy the top of the social hierarchy. Below them are the Ajlaf, converts from middle-ranking Hindu castes. At the bottom are the Arzal – regarded as the equivalent of untouchables, forbidden in certain areas from entering mosques or using public burial grounds, and relegated to menial professions such as scavenging. Together, the Ajlaf and Arzal are known as Pasmanda Muslims – from the Persian for “those who have been left behind.”
The Pasmanda community constitutes nearly 85% of India’s Muslim population, yet remains among the least represented groups in politics, education, and economic life. Discrimination is documented and concrete: separate drinking water vessels for Dalit Halalkhors and Mehtar castes in Muslim-dominated areas, upper-caste Muslims praying in front rows while lower-caste Muslims pray in back rows, and separate burial grounds inaccessible to Dalit Muslims.
Ambedkar himself observed this reality. He noted that caste among Muslims in India was “afflicted by the same social evils” as Hindu society, and recorded that in the 1901 census, Dalit Muslims were described as those “with whom no other Muhammadan would associate.” The names change – from Dom to Mehtar, from Hindu Dhobi to Muslim Dhobi – but the profession, socio-economic status, and educational disadvantage remain intact across generations.
Caste within Sikhism and Buddhism
Sikhism is perhaps the most doctrinally explicit among India’s major religions in rejecting caste. The tenth Sikh Guru institutionalized equality through the ceremony of amrit, where participants of all backgrounds drank from the same vessel. Yet despite Sikh doctrine’s rejection of caste, caste divisions persist in social practices. Dalit Sikhs, known as Mazhabi Sikhs, remain a distinct and often marginalized group within the Sikh community.
Even Buddhism – Ambedkar’s chosen faith, selected specifically for its egalitarian principles – has not been entirely immune. Around 87% of Buddhists in India today are neo-converts, mostly Dalit. While Buddhism has offered Dalits genuine cultural dignity, political mobilization, and psychological empowerment, social discrimination from surrounding communities has not simply dissolved. Dalit Buddhists continue to face hostility and exclusion from upper-caste neighbours regardless of their faith. The transformation within the Buddhist community itself has been more meaningful, but the social environment that surrounds it remains shaped by caste.
The double bind: losing state protection upon conversion
Perhaps the most concrete and legally definable consequence of conversion for Dalits is the loss of state-recognized protections. The Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950 states that no person professing a religion other than Hinduism, Sikhism, or Buddhism can be deemed a member of a Scheduled Caste. In a recent ruling, the Indian Supreme Court confirmed that conversion to Christianity or Islam results in immediate and complete loss of Scheduled Caste status – along with all associated reservations in education, employment, and political representation.
This creates a devastating paradox. In breaking away from Hinduism, Dalits lose the basic constitutional safeguards provided to them. In 1981, thousands of Dalits in southern India converted to Islam to escape social discrimination, only to find they had forfeited their Scheduled Caste privileges. The 1950 Order was amended in 1956 to include Sikh converts and again in 1990 to include Buddhist converts – but it has never been extended to Dalit converts to Christianity or Islam, a distinction critics argue violates the constitutional guarantees of equality under Articles 14 and 15.
Dalit converts are denied protection under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, and the exclusion has been challenged under international human rights treaties, including the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The result is that a Dalit who converts to Christianity or Islam faces discrimination from within their new religious community and loses the legal tools that existed, however imperfectly, to address that discrimination.
This creates a dual vulnerability – marginalized within the Muslim or Christian community because of caste identity, and excluded from affirmative action by the state because of religious identity. The very act of conversion, meant to be an escape, becomes the trigger for a second layer of dispossession.
Why caste survives conversion: the structural explanation
To understand why caste persists so tenaciously across religious boundaries, it is essential to see caste not merely as a set of religious beliefs but as a social structure – one that governs marriage, occupation, land ownership, social interaction, and the distribution of resources. In the landmark constitutional case of Indira Sawhney v. Union of India, the Supreme Court noted that caste is a birth-based phenomenon that transcends religious boundaries and is not limited to Hindu society.
When a Dalit converts, their neighbours, employers, landlords, and in-laws do not convert with them. The social world they inhabit – the village, the neighbourhood, the occupational network – continues to be organized by caste logic. The convert changes their religious identity; the community around them does not change how it categorizes and treats them. Data shows there is more discrimination and less class mobility among people in rural areas, where caste discrimination remains higher among people of all religious backgrounds.
Within the converted religious community itself, the mechanisms that replicate caste – endogamy (marrying within the same caste), hereditary occupational roles, ritual hierarchy, and social distance – survive because they are carried in by converts and rationalized through new religious vocabularies. The Muslim concept of hereditary kafa’ah, used by ulama to support endogamy, effectively justifies South Asian Muslim caste practices within an Islamic framework. In Christianity, the distinction between “Syrian Christians” and “New Christians” performs similar functions. The theological wrapper changes; the social architecture underneath it does not.
Resistance and the limits of religious solutions
Dalit converts have not been passive in the face of this reality. Within Christian communities, Dalit Christians organized protests in the 1990s against caste discrimination in church leadership, and activists like Bama Faustina wrote critically about discrimination by nuns and priests of the Catholic Church. Among Muslims, the Pasmanda movement – led by figures like Ali Anwar, founder of the All India Pasmanda Muslim Mahaz – has sought to mobilize lower-caste Muslims under a shared identity that prioritizes social over religious solidarity. The movement’s slogan – Dalit-pichda ek saman, Hindu ho ya Musalman (All Dalit-backwards are alike, whether Hindu or Muslim) – reflects a sharp recognition that the real axis of oppression is caste, not religion.
Ambedkar himself understood the limits of any purely religious solution. He acknowledged that converting to Buddhism would not bring immediate economic or political gains, but argued that collective conversion could build community consciousness and a sense of collective power outside the Hindu social order. His vision was never that changing one’s religion alone would dismantle caste – it was that building a new community, with new values, new spaces, and new solidarities, could begin to challenge caste from the outside.
That vision has had partial success. Neo-Buddhist communities in Maharashtra have built viharas, educational institutions, and political networks. But the caste system – enforced not by religious scripture alone but by land ownership, marriage networks, social memory, and state policy – has shown a resilience that no single act of conversion has been able to overcome.
What do you think? If caste persists even after a Dalit formally leaves Hinduism, does that suggest the problem of caste is fundamentally a social and economic one rather than a religious one? And what does it mean for a society when its constitutionally guaranteed protections are tied to religious identity rather than to documented historical disadvantage?
References
- https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2018/6/14/dalit-conversions-an-act-of-rebellion-against-caste-supremacy
- https://countercurrents.org/2026/03/anti-conversion-laws-and-their-impact-on-dalits-and-adivasis-an-ambedkarite-perspective/
- https://www.eurasiareview.com/09102024-indian-dalit-leader-ambedkar-explains-mass-conversion-to-buddhism-oped/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalit_Buddhist_movement
- https://www.christiancentury.org/article/2002-06/still-untouchable
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalit_Christian
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste_system_among_South_Asian_Christians
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste_system_among_South_Asian_Muslims
- https://dalitmuslims.wordpress.com/2008/08/10/caste-system-among-south-asian-muslims/
- https://theprint.in/opinion/indias-muslim-community-under-a-churn-85-backward-pasmandas-up-against-15-ashrafs/234599/
- https://ijrar.org/papers/IJRAR22B3437.pdf
- https://journals.library.brandeis.edu/index.php/caste/article/download/503/255/2728
- https://www.indiaspend.com/dalits-are-still-converting-to-buddhism-but-at-a-dwindling-rate-34369
- https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/india/hindu-dalits-converted-to-christianity-islam-cant-claim-scheduled-caste-status-rules-sc/
- https://pclshnlu.wordpress.com/2025/01/03/rights-of-dalit-converts-to-christianity-and-islam-analyzing-the-inherent-bias-in-reservation-policy-for-schedule-caste-in-india/
- https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/marginalized-twice-over-the-struggle-of-dalit-christians-in-india/
Leave a Reply